Cupcakes & Cakes
Specialty Cakes and Desserts
From Key Lime pie made with real Key Limes to Lemon-Blueberry Cheesecake to Revelation Cake (the chocolatiest of chocolate cakes) to the ever-popular Peanut Butter Pie, our wide variety of cakes and desserts are sure to be the star of any meal or celebration. Scroll through our Cake Photo Gallery below and be prepared to be tempted!
View Cake Photo Gallery
Your special day deserves a special cake. Sweet Tooth Café & Bakery is proud to offer custom cake designs for weddings and anniversaries.
- Call or contact us to schedule a free consultation.
- All flavors must be placed in advance and depend on seasonal availability.
- Larger orders may require additional lead time.
- Please book your event date as early as possible.
Delivery within the Virginia Middle Peninsula area (Gloucester, Mathews, Middlesex) is available. Delivery fee based upon mileage.
Contact us to schedule a free consultation
View Wedding Cake Photo Gallery
View Cupcake Photo Gallery
Need that special cake for an event, but want more than one flavor? Cupcake towers are a fun alternative to a traditional wedding, birthday or other party cake and give you the option of having multiple flavor choices.
At Sweet Tooth Café & Bakery…
- Every cupcake tower is a unique and custom placement design.
- Delivery and set up fees start at just $50, which includes a variety of cupcakes tiers/towers available to choose from. Rental price for cupcake stands included in total price.
- Flavor choices are not limited to what is available on our menu. Specialty flavors available throughout the year. Suggestions are always welcome!
Not having a big event but have a hankering for a cupcake?
Come by the café & bakery to see what flavors are fresh each day. A sampling of cupcake flavors listed below, subject to availability.
Dozen Deal $28.00 (A minimum of one dozen per flavor. We aim to have a variety daily of cupcakes in the shop.)
Single Cupcake $2.75
coconut cake topped with almond buttercream, rolled in slivered almonds, coconut and chocolate ganache.
apple and walnut cake topped with a cinnamon cream cheese garnished with walnuts.
apple cake topped with a cider buttercream garnished with a straw.
banana cake filled with a chocolate ganache topped with a vanilla buttercream, garnished with toffee bits, sprinkles, chocolate ganache, caramel and a cherry.
moist blackberry cake with white chocolate chips baked in, topped with blackberry frosting and rimmed in streusel crumbs.
milk chocolate cake filled with cherry compote topped with milk chocolate buttercream, rimmed in chocolate crumbs and topped with a cherry.
rich chocolate cake baked with brownie pieces topped with vanilla buttercream rolled in chocolate sprinkles, chocolate ganache and a cherry.
vanilla cake filled with vanilla cream dipped in chocolate ganache.
yummy apple cake with an apple compote core topped with caramel Swiss meringue buttercream and caramel drizzle.
coffee cake filled with vanilla pudding topped with caramel buttercream and caramel drizzle.
famous carrot cake filled with lots of shredded carrots, pineapple, raisins, and walnuts, topped with our traditional cream cheese icing and a carrot.
Chocolate Covered Pretzel
chocolate cake topped with vanilla buttercream rolled in pretzel pieces, caramel, chocolate ganache and a chocolate covered pretzel.
chocolate cake topped with a strawberry buttercream.
moist banana and chocolate chip cake topped with vanilla buttercream dipped in dark chocolate ganache with a banana chip.
moist coconut cake topped with homemade cream cheese icing rolled in coconut.
chocolate chip cake filled with cookie dough topped with vanilla bean buttercream and a chocolate chip cookie.
Cookies n Cream
vanilla bean cake baked with crushed Oreos topped with a vanilla bean buttercream rolled in Oreo cookie crumbs.
Drive me Bananas
banana cake topped with caramel buttercream and caramel drizzle.
banana chocolate chip cake topped with peanut butter buttercream and fudge drizzle.
vanilla bean cake filled with marshmallow cream, topped with peanut butter buttercream, marshmallow and a cookie.
chocolate cake topped with a gooey delicious toasted coconut-pecan filling drizzled with chocolate ganache.
chocolate cake filled with butterscotch mousse topped with milk chocolate frosting and toffee bits.
Heather’s Lemon Cloud
lemon cake filled with strawberry compote topped with lemon buttercream.
Hot Fudge Sundae’
chocolate cake filled with chocolate whipped buttercream, topped with vanilla bean buttercream rolled in chocolate sprinkles, garnished with fudge and a cherry.
moist pineapple-pecan banana cake frosted with cream cheese frosting.
dark chocolate cake swirled with coffee and Callebaut buttercream.
chocolate cake baked with Kit-Kats topped with a caramel buttercream, caramel drizzle and a Kit-Kat.
lemon pound cake filled with blueberries topped with lemon buttercream and a blueberry.
moist lemon cake filled with lemon curd topped with lemon buttercream and candied sprinkles.
lemon cake topped with coconut cream buttercream garnished with coconut.
signature dark chocolate chip cake with peppermint buttercream, a peppermint patty with a dark chocolate ganache drizzle.
Peanut Butter Bandit
chocolate cake filled with a gooey peanut butter ball frosted with peanut butter buttercream and topped with chocolate ganache and a Reese.
Peanut Butter Oreo
chocolate cake topped with whipped peanut butter buttercream, rolled in Oreo cookie crumbs.
pineapple coconut cake topped with a cream cheese frosting rolled in coconut.
dark chocolate mint cake topped with mint cream cheese frosting drizzled with chocolate ganache and topped with an Andes mint.
chocolate hazelnut cake topped with chocolate-hazelnut buttercream garnished with hazelnut.
vanilla cake topped with vanilla bean buttercream chocolate ganache rolled in chopped peanuts.
dark chocolate cake filled with raspberry compote topped with a chocolate mousse buttercream, rolled in chocolate curls and a raspberry.
vanilla bean cake filled with raspberry compote topped with vanilla bean buttercream and a dollop of raspberry compote.
signature dark chocolate cake filled with raspberry compote dipped in chocolate ganache with an added swirl.
southern velvet cake with baked raspberries, topped with cream cheese, raspberry swirl and white chocolate shavings.
signature dark chocolate cake filled with chocolate ganache topped with milk chocolate buttercream, white chocolate and dark chocolate ganache, chocolate chips and white chocolate shavings….mmmm delicious!!!
chocolate cake filled with marshmallow fluff, topped with chocolate buttercream rolled with nuts and marshmallows.
vanilla bean cake, filled and frosted with our vanilla buttercream rolled in toasted coconut and drizzled with dark chocolate and caramel.
signature chocolate cake topped with caramel buttercream, cashews, pretzels and caramel drizzle.
signature dark chocolate cake atop graham cracker crust, filled with chocolate ganache, topped with a light marshmallow whip, garnished with graham cracker crumbs, chocolate shavings and a graham cracker.
chocolate cake filled with snicker pieces topped with chocolate buttercream, snickers, caramel and fudge drizzle.
vanilla cake with cinnamon buttercream and a cinnamon-sugar topping.
chocolate cake topped with cream cheese icing rolled in coconut.
Southern Banana Pudding
banana cake filled with vanilla pudding, topped with a Swiss mergune buttercream, rolled in crushed up wafers.
traditional spice cake topped with a maple cream cheese icing and a caramelized walnut.
Strawberry Cream Pie
buttermilk cake, stuffed with fresh strawberries frosted with vanilla cream edged in pie crust crumbs and topped with a fresh strawberry.
vanilla bean cake filled with strawberry champagne compote, frosted with a champagne buttercream with a strawberry for garnish.
moist strawberry cake filled with fresh strawberries, topped with white chocolate cream cheese frosting and candid sprinkles.
vanilla bean cake filled with strawberry compote topped with vanilla buttercream and a dollop of strawberry compote.
Surprise… It’s a Girl!!
vanilla bean or chocolate cake infused with pink buttercream topped with our vanilla buttercream and sprinkles. (Great idea for baby reveal parties)
Surprise…It’s a Boy!!
vanilla bean or chocolate cake infused with blue buttercream topped with our vanilla buttercream and sprinkles. – (Great idea for baby reveal parties)
signature dark chocolate cake filled with cream dipped in chocolate ganache with squiggles.
signature dark chocolate cake filled with Carmel and pecans, topped with milk chocolate frosting, topped with chocolate and caramel drizzle and pecans.
dark espresso cake frosted with a light espresso whip and topped with a chocolate covered coffee bean.
moist white cake (with a hint of almond), topped with buttercream and sprinkled with white and sliver sprinkles and a white editable pearl.
white cake baked with colorful sprinkles rolled in colorful sprinkles.
southern red velvet cake frosted with traditional cream cheese icing with a red heart.
vanilla bean cake frosted with vanilla buttercream (or chocolate) and sprinkles.
signature dark chocolate cake, with milk chocolate frosting, topped with chocolate curls.
Black and White
vanilla cake topped with chocolate frosting.
pumpkin cake topped with a cinnamon cream cheese frosting and candied pecans.
sweet potato cake topped with a mascarpone frosting and a pecan.
chocolate cake infused with peppermint topped with a peppermint buttercream and garnished with a candid candy cane.
pumpkin cake baked with cheesecake topped with cream cheese frosting and caramel.
View Photo Gallery